Is Andersons Bay, Dunedin a good suburb to invest in?
Andersons Bay is one of Dunedin's most established and consistently performing residential suburbs. To understand how it stacks up for property investors, Paragon Property Ratings completed an independent assessment of a 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom freehold townhouse in the suburb in August 2026.
The property received an overall investment score of 80/100 - a Very Strong rating - with a confidence score of 98/100.
Here is what the suburb profile and that assessment tell us.
About Andersons Bay
Andersons Bay sits on the eastern shore of the Otago Harbour, approximately 10 minutes from Dunedin's CBD. It is a predominantly residential suburb that attracts a stable mix of owner-occupiers, professional tenants, and families - a demographic profile that tends to support lower vacancy rates and longer tenancies than higher-density or student-focused areas.
The suburb consistently ranks well on the indicators that matter most to property investors:
School zoning: Andersons Bay sits within a high-performing school zone, with an average school decile of 8.9. Strong school zoning drives family demand and underpins long-term desirability in ways that are difficult to replicate in suburbs without it.
Crime and safety: Crime rates in Andersons Bay are well below the national average, supporting both tenant demand and long-term asset value.
Demographics: 47% of residents earn $70,000 or more, and 53% are of working age. This points to solid tenant affordability and lower arrears and vacancy risk compared to suburbs with a more transient or lower-income rental base.
Market liquidity: Transaction volumes and days on market in Andersons Bay reflect a stable, active local market. Liquidity is an often-overlooked factor in suburb selection - it determines how cleanly an investor can exit when the time comes.
Hazard profile: The suburb carries no flood zone exposure based on current hazard mapping.
What Paragon's Assessment Found
Paragon assessed a 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom freehold townhouse in Andersons Bay. Key figures from the assessment:
Metric | Result |
Overall score | 80/100 - very strong |
Confidence score | 98/100 - extremely high |
Asking price | $599,000 |
Estimated rent | $650/w |
Gross yield | 5.64% |
Suburb 20-year historical growth rate | 5.08% |
Across the four assessment pillars:
Build Quality (77/100): The build specification is competent, with materials appropriate for the New Zealand climate. Title is freehold, offering full land and dwelling ownership.
Cashflow (82/100): A gross yield of 5.64% represents strong income performance at this price point. Holding costs at current interest rates are within a reasonable range, though the position shows increased sensitivity if rates rise materially.
Growth Profile (78/100): Andersons Bay's 20-year capital growth rate of 5.08% per annum is reasonably. Growth is assessed as solid and defensible, driven by genuine occupier demand rather than speculative activity.
Location & Risk (82/100): No flood risk was identified, meaning no natural hazard discount was applied to the overall score. Market liquidity is healthy and all required project consents were in place at the time of assessment.
Andersons Bay in the Context of Dunedin Investment
Dunedin has attracted growing interest from New Zealand property investors over the past decade, driven by relative affordability compared to Auckland and Wellington, a large and stable tenant base, and steady long-term capital growth.
Within Dunedin, Andersons Bay sits at the more stable and defensive end of the market - it does not offer the highest yields in the city, but it consistently presents with low risk, strong demographics, and a clear exit pathway.
For investors comparing Dunedin suburbs, Andersons Bay is worth examining closely if the priority is a lower-risk entry point with proven long-term performance rather than a high-yield, higher-risk position.
About Paragon Property Ratings
Paragon Property Ratings provides independent, data-driven property assessments for New Zealand residential investments. Reports cover build quality, cashflow, growth profile, and location and risk - scored across a structured framework with full confidence scoring.
Paragon does not sell property and receives no commissions. All reports represent independent analysis only and do not constitute financial or investment advice.
Check out other properties Paragon has rated → Properties We Have Rated
Note: This rating applies to the specific property assessed. It is not a rating of Andersons Bay as a whole and does not constitute a purchase recommendation. Paragon does not sell property and receives no commissions.
_________________________________________________________________________
Common questions about capital growth:
Is Andersons Bay a good suburb to invest in?
Andersons Bay has a strong demographic and risk profile - low crime, high school decile zoning, solid tenant demographics, no flood risk, and healthy market liquidity. A freehold townhouse assessed there in August 2026 received a score of 80/100 (Very Strong) from Paragon Property Ratings. Whether any specific property in the suburb suits a particular investor depends on individual circumstances - Paragon's assessments are independent analysis, not financial advice.
What did Paragon Property Ratings score the Andersons Bay property?
The assessed 2-bedroom freehold townhouse received an overall score of 80/100 - Very Strong - with a confidence score of 98/100.
What is the gross yield on the property Paragon assessed in Andersons Bay?
The assessed gross yield is 5.64%, based on an asking price of $599,000 and an estimated weekly rent of $650 per week.
What does a Paragon property rating include?
Each Paragon rating covers four pillars - Build Quality, Cashflow, Growth Profile, and Location & Risk - alongside a flood risk assessment and a confidence score reflecting data quality across the assessment. Reports are independent; Paragon does not sell property and receives no commissions. You can view a sample report here. And to order a report, click here.
